Painting & Coating Industry (PCI) logo Powder coating summit logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Painting & Coating Industry (PCI) logo Powder coating summit logo
  • NEWS
    • Latest News
    • Market Trends & Reports
    • Price Alerts
    • Subscribe to eNewsletters
    • Global Top 10/ PCI 25
    • Weekly Featured Article
    • COATLE Word Game
  • PRODUCTS
    • Product News
    • Must See Products and Services
  • MATERIALS
    • Additives
    • Resins/Polymers
    • Pigments
    • Equipment
    • Distributors
  • TECHNOLOGIES
    • Adhesives
    • Architectural Coatings
    • Industrial Coatings
    • Nanotechnology
    • Powder Coatings
    • Solventborne
    • Special Purpose Coatings
    • Sustainability
    • UV Coatings
    • Waterborne
    • FINISHING
      • Finishing News
      • Finishing Technologies
      • Finishing Equipment
    • RESOURCES
      • Columns
        • Ask Joe Powder
        • Did you know?
        • Distribution Dive
        • Focus on Canada
        • Formulating With Mike
        • Innovation Insights
        • Moody's Coatings Conundrums
        • Powder Coating Perspectives
        • Target the Market
        • TiO2 Insider
      • Blogs
        • Editor's Viewpoint
        • Industry Insights
      • Coatings Supplier Handbook
      • Podcasts and Videos
        • COAT-IT! Podcast
        • Videos/PCI TV
      • PCI Store
      • eBooks
      • Sponsor Insights
      • White Papers
      • COATLE Word Game
    • EVENTS
      • Coatings Trends & Technologies Summit
      • Paint and Coatings Academy
      • Webinars
      • Calendar of Events
      • Lifetime Achievement Award
    • DIRECTORIES
      • Buyer's Guide
      • Equipment Directory
      • Materials Directory
    • EMAGAZINE
      • Current Issue
      • eMagazine Archive
      • China Issue Archive
      • Editorial Advisory Board
    • CONTACT
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise
      • Subscribe to eMagazine
      • Subscribe to eNewsletters
    Paint and Coatings AdditivesEU TodayArticles From Europe

    Coatings’ Cobalt Replacement Challenge

    Where Are We Now?

    By Ronald Hage
    Coatings’ Cobalt Replacement Challenge
    Coatings’ Cobalt Replacement Challenge

    Figure 1

    Coatings’ Cobalt Replacement Challenge

    Figure 2

    Coatings’ Cobalt Replacement Challenge
    Coatings’ Cobalt Replacement Challenge
    Coatings’ Cobalt Replacement Challenge
    June 1, 2016

    Cobalt (Co) soaps, or more accurately, cobalt carboxylates, is the collective description for a range of partially soluble compounds formed by cobalt in combination with a range of organic acids. These typically have a carbon chain with between 8 and 10 carbon atoms; the most common being ethylhexanoate (C8), isononanoate (C9) and neodecanoate (C10) or, in selected applications, natural naphthenates.

    These substances are used as a primary drier or siccative in alkyd resin-based paints that make up about 40% of the market and are used widely for both decorative and functional end uses. An example of a typical linseed oil-based alkyd resin is given in Figure 1. The coatings sector today is well versed in the regulatory issue that cobalt has come to present. Working in close co-operation with paint makers, research and development groups have found some solutions, and a number of paint makers already make claim to being “cobalt-free,” but how did we get there, where are we now and how do these developments inform the next step?

    Concerns with Cobalt

    The use of cobalt became widespread following the removal of lead in paints. However, there has been a long-running debate in industry about the issue of bioavailability of cobalt and read-across.

    The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) is considering several cobalt compounds for authorization under REACH, and the Cobalt Reach Consortium chose to self-classify 12 cobalt substances under the EU CLP Regulation as Toxic to Reproduction Category 2: more commonly referred to as CMR 2. This wider list now includes a range of commonly used carboxylates.

    The Dutch Authorities have informed ECHA of their intention to submit CLH (harmonized classification and labeling) dossiers for cobalt and cobalt compounds for classification as carcinogenic 1B and reprotoxic 1B.

    Alongside these regulatory moves in Europe, the National Toxicology Program in the United States has written several reports on cobalt, and in June 2015 issued a draft report concluding that cobalt and certain cobalt compounds are reasonably anticipated to be human carcinogens.

    With the reclassification of cobalt looking likely, there is now added impetus on the coatings sector to continue the search for alternatives that can deliver comparable drying performance to cobalt, while working in harmony with other technical additives. The team behind Catexel was the first to develop and market, via OM Group in the United States, a viable cobalt replacement product with its iron-based FeONIX technology, and the chemistry behind this important breakthrough is discussed later in this article. The team has since been harnessing the full range of its iron- and manganese-based platforms with the proven potential to present long-term solutions that address the paint manufacturers’ overriding concerns about maintaining performance without compromise and while remaining cost effective.

    A Catalyst for Change

    The search for a cobalt substitute has not been an easy one, and there is no such thing as a simple drop-in cobalt-free solution. The universally useful cobalt soaps leave a big hole to fill and one that needs a range of optimized solutions.

    In particular, any viable alternative must be:

    • applicable in all alkyd-based (solvent-based, water-based and high solids) coating segments, and in all geographies;
    • fully compatible with other materials used in paints and maintain the aesthetic, protective and functional properties of the coating;
    • environmentally sustainable;
    • cost effective.

    While posing a troublesome challenge for manufacturers, the regulatory threat jeopardizing cobalt’s long-term viability does provide an opportunity for the makers of paints, inks and composites to consider innovative technologies.

    In this search, a variety of substitute siccatives have been explored, in particular platforms based on manganese (Mn) or iron (Fe) either as a complex or as a redox-active transition-metal salt combined with a ligand.

    Manganese Improves Drying Performance

    Traditional manganese soaps, while more active than iron, are still less active than cobalt soaps. What is more, the presence of Mn(III) in commercial manganese soap solutions makes the substance intensely colored, posing a challenge for paint manufacturers. To counteract this, in many cases, the traditional Mn soaps still need to be formulated with cobalt soaps to reduce the levels of both metals. Alternatively, they need to be activated by the inclusion of a ligand.

    By choosing an appropriate ligand, which upon binding to the metal ion tunes the properties in such a way that the autoxidation reactivity within the alkyd resin is enhanced, the level of active Mn-based drier can be reduced.

    As Figure 2 demonstrates, a number of nitrogen-based ligand donors have shown to improve the paint drying activity of Mn salts significantly, leading to potential alternatives to cobalt soaps.

    It should be noted, however, that alongside paint drying times and color of the metal drier, other parameters still need to be fully explored and understood to make a proper assessment of the impact of a new paint drying catalyst. These parameters include: the stability in the paint formulation (due to decomposition of the active drier or adsorption on pigments or fillers), color formation of the paint layer upon ageing (yellowing) and hardness development of the paint layer. In fact, a more complete overview of Mn, as well as Fe, paint drying catalysts can be found in a recent review.1

    The addition of 2,2’-bipyridine (bpy) (Figure 2) is one avenue under exploration. Adding bpy leads to improved drying activity of Mn soaps and is therefore applied at levels of Mn that are similar to those used for cobalt. Despite its improved drying capabilities, however, the solution is still colored to some extent, which does limit its applicability. Recent detailed investigations have revealed that upon mixing Mn soaps and bpy, multinuclear complexes may be formed, and these could be involved in the paint drying activity.2

    Manganese complexes using 1,4,7-trimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononane (Me3TACN, Figure 2) and 1,2-bis(4,7-dimethyl-1,4,7-triazacyclononan-1-yl)-ethane (Me4DTNE, Figure 2) as ligands have also been studied as well-defined complexes and as mixtures of manganese salts. The manganese complexes or mixtures with triazacyclononane-based ligands have received considerable attention as alkyd paint drying catalysts. Following is a summary of different publications and patent applications.

    [MnIV2(m-O)3(Me3TACN)2](PF6)2 was studied in model paint formulations and more extensively on model substrates such as ethyllinoleate at Eindhoven University.3 The paint drying activity, compared to Mn soaps, was clearly improved, and the Mn level’s ability to furnish good drying activity was similar to that of the cobalt level under the same conditions. Activity in both solventborne and waterborne paints was observed. Improvement of the drying activity was highlighted when using other Mn-Me3TACN complexes, such as [MnIII2(m-O)(m-RCOO)2(Me3TACN)2]2+ and [MnIV2(m-O)3(Me3TACN)2](CH3COO)2 complexes.4,5 Also improvements in the drying performance were recorded as a result of mixing ligand and manganese salts.6,7,8 Combining [MnIV2(m-O)3(Me3TACN)2]2+ and Me3TACN can lead to enhanced paint drying activity, thereby lowering the concentration of Mn required in the paint formulation.9

    Other studies show that manganese complexes with the bridged TACN ligand, Me4DTNE, actively aid paint drying too.10 Further research has highlighted that mixtures of ligand and manganese salts are much more active than the well-defined [MnIVMnIII(m-O)2(m-H3CCOO)(Me4DTNE)]Cl2 complex.

    Similarly, formulating Me3TACN, Me4DTNE or bpy ligands into the alkyd resin (without manganese) can lead to storage-stable mixtures that upon addition of manganese salts show paint drying activity.11

    Diazacycloheptane-based ligands – a new class of ligands – are being explored as alternative catalysts with Mn. The advantage of these is that by using different building blocks, a variety of the diazacycloheptane-based ligands can be obtained, each having slightly different properties. This in turn tunes the paint drying activity, but may also change other properties of the siccatives. Further research into other classes of manganese catalysts is ongoing and will be published in due course.12 Examples of other Mn complexes have been reported to be active for paint drying and these are discussed in a recent review paper.1

    Iron Based Solutions

    Alongside manganese, iron-based alternatives are showing further potential for development. Traditional iron soaps have much lower reactivity towards alkyd resin curing than cobalt soaps and, like manganese, are more intensely colored. As a result, they have been put to more limited use, especially in high-temperature curing – for example in stoving enamels.

    Iron catalysts are also being investigated, and while being generally less active than Fe soaps, some show a very good paint drying activity. An example of an active iron complex can be found in Figure 2. Here, the ligand structure is a pentadentate nitrogen ligand based on bispidon. This iron-bispidon catalyst, which is the aforementioned FeONIX technology, was originally developed for food-oil stain removal activity in detergents, and it was shown that autoxidation radical chemistry reactions are involved in the removal of such stains.13

    Following on from this work, other studies discovered that the autoxidation radical chemistry operative for food oil stain bleaching is very similar to that of alkyd paint hardening catalyzed by cobalt soap siccatives. Initial experiments were carried out using linseed oil as an indicator for activity in paint and ink formulations, and good drying activity was observed with it and other catalysts.14

    Subsequently, an iron bispidon catalyst was further developed for this application. More details on the reactivity and paint drying activity of this Catexel catalyst, to which OM Group currently holds the IP rights for use in inks, coatings and composites and markets under the Borchi Oxy Coat banner, can be found in Reference 14.

    Alternative iron-based catalysts for more widespread use are also being explored, namely those based on diazacycloheptane ligands (Figure 2),15 and have shown improved paint drying activity (compared to cobalt soaps and Fe soaps). A recent publication discusses these and other iron catalysts in more detail.1

    Looking to the Future 

    With the reclassification of cobalt-based alkyd curing catalysts highly likely, research is ongoing to find transition metal ion alternatives that also boast improved safety and environmental profiles.

    While in the last two decades Mn and Fe catalysts have been found to offer higher drying activity than cobalt, manganese and iron soaps, other parameters are still yet to be explored that may impact the formulation of coatings in the future. As paint compositions have previously been optimized for cobalt soaps, manufacturers may need to make some adaptions to ensure new Mn or Fe siccatives work in the most optimal manner.

    While keeping these aspects in mind, the search for metal complexes based on manganese and iron, and the accelerating effect of polydentate ligands on existing driers has led to the discovery and development of multiple product platforms able to meet the varying needs of the paint maker. Catexel is at the forefront of this discovery and development, and is helping industry to make the change from cobalt soaps to manganese and iron driers, as well as also looking to the future with next-generation technologies under development.

    With more viable alternatives very much on the horizon, paint manufacturers will be looking for a range of solutions that not only replace, but in many aspects seek to improve on the performance of cobalt and offer low-dose, highly selective products that do not experience the high price volatility and geopolitical issues experienced by cobalt.

    Now and in the future, paint makers can look to innovative partners to tailor molecules for any and all applications as part of the everyday process of improving the aesthetics, performance and environmental profile of coatings in general and paint in particular. 

    References

    1   de Boer, J.W.; Maaijen, K.; Hage, R. Manuscript in publication (2016).

    2   van Gorkum, R.; Bouwman, E. Coord. Chem. Rev., 249, 1709 (2005).

    3   Oyman, Z.O.; Ming, W.; van der Linde, R.; ter Borg, J.;  Bieleman, J.H. Surf. Coatings. Int. Part B, Coatings Transactions, 88, 269 (2005).

    4   Jansen, J.; Kleuskens, E.C.; van Summeren, R.; Alsters, P.L. EP2534215B.

    5   Jansen, J.; Bergman, F.A.C.; Kleuskens, E.C.; Hage, R. WO2011/098584.

    6   Meijer, M.D.; van Weelde, E.; van Dijk, J.T.M.; Flapper, J. WO2013/092441.

    7    Meijer, M.D.; van Weelde, E.; van Dijk, J.T.M.; Flapper, J. EP2794787B.

    8   de Boer, J.W.; Maaijen, K.; Hage, R. WO2015/114349.

    9    Meijer, M.D.; Flapper, J. WO2014/095670.

    10 de Boer, J.W.; Maaijen, K.; Hage, R. WO2014/122432.

    11 de Boer, J.W.; Maaijen, K.; Hage, R. WO2014/122433.

    12 Maaijen, K.; Hage, R. patent filed on new Mn-based siccatives.

    13 de Boer, J.W.; Wesenhagen, P.V.; Wenker, E.C.M.; Maaijen, K.; Gol, F.; Gibbs, H.; Hage, R. Eur. J. Inorg.Chem., 3581-3591 (2013).

    14 Hage, R.; Wesenhagen, P.V. WO2008/003652.

    15 de Boer, J.W.; Maaijen, K.; Hage, R. WO2014/122434.

    Share This Story

    Looking for a reprint of this article?
    From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

    Dr. Ronald Hage, Chief Technology Officer, Catexel Limited, Leiden, The Netherlands

    Recommended Content

    JOIN TODAY
    to unlock your recommendations.

    Already have an account? Sign In

    • PCI-0724-Global10-Feature-1440.png

      2024 Global Top 10: Top Paint and Coatings Companies

      Who ranks on top? PCI’s annual ranking of the top 10...
      Global Top 10 and PCI 25
      By: Courtney Bassett
    • PCI-0724-PCI25-Feature-1440.png

      2024 PCI 25: Top Paint and Coatings Companies

      PCI's annual ranking of the top 25 North American paint...
      Global Top 10 and PCI 25
      By: Courtney Bassett
    • pci1022-Kinaltek-Lead-1170.jpg

      A Novel Pigment Production Technology

      Following an extensive R&D program that demonstrated...
      Paint and Coating Pigments
      By: Jawad Haidar and Nitin Soni
    You must login or register in order to post a comment.

    Report Abusive Comment

    Subscribe For Free!
    • eMagazine
    • eNewsletter
    • Online Registration
    • Subscription Customer Service

    More Videos

    Sponsored Content

    Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the PCI audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of PCI or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

    close
    • paint sprayer in a workshop
      Sponsored byallnex

      Enabling Performance and Compliance: allnex Introduces a New Line of VOC Exempt Solvent-Borne Resins

    • various shades of orange pigments and colorants
      Sponsored byVibrantz Technologies

      Solid Colorant Technology Paves the Way for a Sustainable, High-Performance Future in Coatings

    Popular Stories

    A collage of products using non-PFAS

    A Surge in Non-PFAS Releases

    Default Aerospace Image

    PPG Plans Major Aerospace Facility

    US tariff on British product import trade war cargo shipping container

    Tariffs Reshape Coatings Supply Strategies



    PCI Buyers Guide

    Submit a Request for Proposal (RFP) to suppliers of your choice with details on what you need with a click of a button

    Start your RFP

    Browse our Buyers Guide for manufacturers and distributors of all types of coatings products and much more!

    Find Suppliers

    Events

    January 1, 2030

    Webinar Sponsorship Information

    For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

    View All Submit An Event

    Poll

    Longest-running laboratory experiment

    What is the longest-running laboratory experiment?
    View Results Poll Archive

    Products

    Automotive Paints and Coatings, 2nd Edition

    Automotive Paints and Coatings, 2nd Edition

    Now in its second edition and still the only book of its kind, this is an authoritative treatment of all stages of the coating process.

    See More Products
    pci  webinar april 2025

    PCI CASE EBOOK

    Related Articles

    • pci0311-OMG-lg.jpg

      Cobalt-Free Catalyst Gives New Life to the Alkyd Coatings Market

      See More
    • VCT hospital floor

      PFAS Replacement in Polish Systems

      See More
    • Open paint cans with colorful paint and brush

      A New High-Performance Alternative to Cobalt Driers

      See More

    Related Products

    See More Products
    • biopolymer.jpg

      Biopolymer-Based Films and Coatings Trends and Challenges

    • Kevin-Biller-PC-BOOK.jpg

      Powder Coatings - Foundation for the Novice Formulator (ebook)

    • nanostructuredthinfilms.jpg

      Nanostructured Thin Films and Coatings: Mechanical Properties

    See More Products

    Events

    View AllSubmit An Event
    • September 3, 2025

      Coatings Trends & Technologies Summit

      The Coatings Trends & Technologies (CTT) Summit is an annual conference for both liquid and powder coatings formulators and manufacturers to discuss innovations in coatings technology. This event combines high-quality technical presentations, a resource-rich exhibit hall, and dedicated networking opportunities to connect scientific minds, foster innovation, and cultivate game-changing new ideas!
    View AllSubmit An Event
    ×

    Keep the info flowing with our eNewsletters!

    Get the latest industry updates tailored your way.

    JOIN TODAY!
    • RESOURCES
      • Advertise
      • Contact Us
      • Directories
      • Store
      • Want More
    • SIGN UP TODAY
      • Create Account
      • eMagazine
      • eNewsletters
      • Customer Service
      • Manage Preferences
    • SERVICES
      • Marketing Services
      • Reprints
      • Market Research
      • List Rental
      • Survey & Sample
    • STAY CONNECTED
      • LinkedIn
      • Facebook
      • Youtube
      • X (Twitter)
    • PRIVACY
      • PRIVACY POLICY
      • TERMS & CONDITIONS
      • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
      • PRIVACY REQUEST
      • ACCESSIBILITY

    Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

    Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing