Painting & Coating Industry (PCI) logo Powder coating summit logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Join Today
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Painting & Coating Industry (PCI) logo Powder coating summit logo
  • NEWS
    • Latest News
    • PCI News Now
    • Market Trends & Reports
    • Finishing News
    • Price Alerts
    • Global Top 10/ PCI 25
  • PRODUCTS
    • Product News
    • Featured Products
    • Must See Products and Services
  • MATERIALS
    • Additives
    • Resins/Polymers
    • Pigments
    • Equipment
    • Distributors
  • TECHNOLOGIES
    • Adhesives
    • Architectural Coatings
    • Finishing Articles
    • Finishing Technologies
    • Finishing Equipment
    • Industrial Coatings
    • Nanotechnology
    • Powder Coatings
    • Solventborne
    • Special Purpose Coatings
    • Sustainability
    • UV Coatings
    • Waterborne
  • EVENTS
    • Coatings Trends & Technologies Summit
    • Paint and Coatings Academy
    • Webinars
    • Calendar of Events
    • Lifetime Achievement Award
  • DIRECTORIES
    • Buyer's Guide
    • Equipment Directory
    • Materials Directory
  • RESOURCES
    • Columns
      • Did you know?
      • Distribution Dive
      • Formulating With Mike
      • Innovation Insights
      • Powder Coating Perspectives
      • TiO2 Insider
    • Blogs
      • Editor's Viewpoint
      • Industry Insights
    • Coatings Supplier Handbook
    • COAT-IT! Podcast
    • Videos
    • PCI Store
    • eBooks
    • Sponsor Insights
  • EMAGAZINE
    • eMagazine
    • Archive Issues
    • Editorial Advisory Board
    • CONTACT
    • Advertise
  • JOIN!
Paint and Coating Resins & PolymersIndustrial CoatingsSolventborne Coatings

The Solution to Saul’s Double Rub Debacle

By Keith M. Moody
moodys coating conundrums
November 3, 2020

Editor’s note: As we read in PCI’s October issue, Saul Vance had formulated a coil coating formulation that passed MEK double rubs in the lab when formulated with a fluorosurfactant flow control additive. But, when this additive was replaced with an acrylic flow control additive on the coil line, the formulation didn’t pass MEK (Methyl Ethyl Ketone) double rubs. Why did this change result in poor MEK double rub results? How did Saul’s boss, Wyatt Walsh, know that Saul’s formulation didn’t have the required crosslink density?

 

Saul Vance had developed the formulation over the previous three months in his lab and used a very simple formulation. The polyester resin was one that Big Time Paint had made for years. The only other ingredients were the standard melamine crosslinker, catalyst and TiO2 pigment.

Coil coating formulations have to balance excellent flexibility with excellent crosslink density. The coating should not crack when bent upon itself, known as a zero t-bend. Yet, the coating has to have good solvent resistance as measured by the MEK double rub test. Saul worked hard to balance these properties by optimizing the levels of each of the ingredients in the coating. He calculated the correct molecular weight of the polyester, the correct hydroxyl functionality of the polyester, and the amount of melamine and catalyst to give a consistent crosslink density.

Saul had formulated the coating to pass the same test protocol that his customer would use: MEK double rubs to measure crosslink density, pencil hardness to measure surface hardness and T-bends to measure flexibility. Like MEK double rub testing, pencil hardness and T-bend testing were fast and easy tests that coil coaters use on the line. The hardness had to pass a minimum to prevent marring on the line, especially when the coil was rewound and shipped to the customer.

Saul had also included a small amount, only 0.5%, of a fluorosurfactant, to overcome surface defects and help flow out on the coil line. Wyatt Walsh realized that the MEK double rub test was giving a false positive test because of the addition of the fluorosurfactant additive.

The problem is that the double rub test is only a good quantifiable test if the MEK is a good solvent for the coating and behaves the same way for all coating systems. The test only works if the MEK wets the surface of the coating, penetrates the coating and swells the cross-linked polymer. If there is enough crosslink density in the coating, the MEK will not remove the coating upon rubbing with the cheesecloth.

Wyatt knew the fluorosurfactant was acting as a very efficient barrier to the MEK penetrating the polymer. Fluorine-containing surfactants are used as additives in coil coating formulations because they overcome many of the flow problems seen on high-speed coil lines. However, the fluorosurfactants impart very low surface tension to the coating, especially when they migrate to the surface during curing. At the surface of the film, the fluorosurfactants stop the MEK from penetrating the coating film and swelling the polymer. Besides imparting low surface tension, the fluorosurfactants make it difficult for the MEK to wet out the surface because of their inherent insolubility in most solvents.

On the coil line, without the fluorosurfactant additive in the formulation, the MEK was able to swell and attack the film. In the QC lab, the MEK double rub testing was demonstrating that the coating didn’t cure to the extent needed by the coil coater.

In addition to giving a false positive MEK double rub test, the fluorosurfactant was improving the slip resistance of the coating. When Saul ran hardness of the coating by checking pencil rubs, the fluorosurfactant allowed the pencil to slip across the surface without biting into the surface. The fluorosurfactant was not allowing the pencil to mar the coating. In the lab, Saul was getting pencil hardness units indicative of a good cure and getting another false positive test.

If Saul had taken the time to determine the true crosslink density of the coating by running one of the many analytical tests available to determine crosslink density, he would have seen that the formulation wasn’t curing sufficiently. But these tests are time-consuming, often take specialized equipment, require trained personnel to interpret, and are often difficult because the film has to be analyzed free from the substrate.

The addition of this one additive had generated two false positives in his coating testing. Wyatt insisted that Saul test the cure without the flow additive and then, if acceptable, check again with the flow additive.

After Saul spent the next two weeks reformulating his system and doing the appropriate crosslink network analysis, Wyatt thought it appropriate to mark the occasion with a small token to recognize Saul’s hard work. Wyatt came into Saul’s office holding a small toy, a Rubik’s cube, as a gift. Wyatt held the toy in his hands and said, “This toy is a good example of the difficulties involved in formulating coatings. A single, seemingly insignificant, change in one ingredient, one additive, in a coating formulation can sometimes greatly impact the properties in ways difficult to predict.” As he spoke, he took the Rubik’s puzzle in both hands and twisted the cube 90 degrees, showing Saul the face that now had all the same color. Wyatt continued, “much like how twisting the cube can result in moving the correct color to one face, while simultaneously changing the colors on the other three faces in unpredictable and sometimes detrimental ways.”

KEYWORDS: Coil Coatings Solvents

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

By Keith M. Moody, Training and Consulting, Johnson City, TN

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
to unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • Double exposure of creative chemistry concept on laptop background, research and development concept

    Inside the AI Shift in Coatings

    Industry leaders share real-world examples of how AI is...
    Paint and Coating Resins & Polymers
    By: PCI Editorial Staff
  • Global Top 10 and PCI Logo

    2026 Global Top 10: Top Paint and Coatings Companies

    See how the world’s largest paint and coatings companies...
    Global Top 10 and PCI 25
    By: Courtney Bassett
  • The 2026 PCI 25

    2026 PCI 25: Top Paint and Coatings Companies

    See how North America's largest paint and coatings...
    Global Top 10 and PCI 25
    By: Courtney Bassett
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Manage My Account
  • Join Paint & Coatings Industry
  • Manage My Preferences
  • Customer Service

More Videos

Popular Stories

Mergers and aquisitions

Evonik Holds Off on BASF Takeover Talks

industry news

Dozens Treated After Toledo Chemical Release

Breaking News

H.B. Fuller to Close Seven Sites in Supply-Chain Overhaul

Events

November 19, 2026

Reformulating Paints with AI: Turn Change into a Competitive Advantage

Join industry leaders and experts for real case studies showing how AI helps R&D teams use existing paint formulation and test data to evaluate alternatives, predict trade-offs, and prioritize experiments.

December 10, 2026

PC Academy: Waterborne Polymers and Film Formation

The trend towards waterborne polymers in the paint and coatings industry is clear; highlighting their environmentally friendly nature, regulatory considerations, growing market demand, and meeting sustainability goals.

View All Submit An Event

Products

Powder Coatings - Foundation for the Novice Formulator (ebook)

Powder Coatings - Foundation for the Novice Formulator (ebook)

See More Products
PCI news now promo ad

Related Articles

  • moodys coating conundrums

    Saul’s Double Rub Debacle

    See More
  • moodys coating conundrums

    The Solution to Al’s Frigid Fiasco

    See More
  • Moody's coating conundrums

    Moody's Coatings Conundrums: Answer to Saul’s Un-Sellable Formulation

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • pce feb 2020

    PCI February 2020 Issue

  • Kevin-Biller-PC-BOOK.jpg

    Powder Coatings - Foundation for the Novice Formulator (ebook)

See More Products

Related Directories

  • Catalynt Solutions Inc.

    Catalynt Solutions, Inc. is one of North America's largest certified women-owned suppliers and service providers of raw materials and ingredients. We offer exclusive manufacturer relationships, specialty-market intelligence, import/export expertise, and logistics support, along with contract manufacturing, toll blending, quality control services, and specialty chemistries. Our unmatched customer service anticipates industry disruptions and exceeds our clients’ needs.
  • Cast Aluminum Solutions

    CAST-X Heaters from Cast Aluminum Solutions are widely used in solvents heating applications, as well as warming processes for paints, coatings, adhesives, and drying gases. CAST-X Circulation Heaters can safely heat flammable chemicals of all types. CAS also offers custom-engineered heaters for curing applications. Located near Chicago, CAS serves OEMs and end-users worldwide.
×

Keep the info flowing with our eNewsletters!

Get the latest industry updates tailored your way.

JOIN TODAY!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Manufacturing Division
  • JOIN TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eMagazine
    • Newsletters
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Marketing Services
    • Reprints
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey & Sample
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Youtube
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2026. All Rights Reserved BNP Media, Inc. and BNP Media II, LLC.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing