Painting & Coating Industry (PCI) logo Powder coating summit logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Painting & Coating Industry (PCI) logo Powder coating summit logo
  • NEWS
    • Latest News
    • Market Trends & Reports
    • Price Alerts
    • Subscribe to eNewsletters
    • Global Top 10/ PCI 25
    • Weekly Featured Article
    • COATLE Word Game
  • PRODUCTS
    • Product News
    • Must See Products and Services
  • MATERIALS
    • Additives
    • Resins/Polymers
    • Pigments
    • Equipment
    • Distributors
  • TECHNOLOGIES
    • Adhesives
    • Architectural Coatings
    • Industrial Coatings
    • Nanotechnology
    • Powder Coatings
    • Solventborne
    • Special Purpose Coatings
    • Sustainability
    • UV Coatings
    • Waterborne
    • FINISHING
      • Finishing News
      • Finishing Technologies
      • Finishing Equipment
    • RESOURCES
      • Columns
        • Ask Joe Powder
        • Did you know?
        • Distribution Dive
        • Focus on Canada
        • Formulating With Mike
        • Innovation Insights
        • Moody's Coatings Conundrums
        • Powder Coating Perspectives
        • Target the Market
        • TiO2 Insider
      • Blogs
        • Editor's Viewpoint
        • Industry Insights
      • Coatings Supplier Handbook
      • Podcasts and Videos
        • COAT-IT! Podcast
        • Videos/PCI TV
      • PCI Store
      • eBooks
      • Sponsor Insights
      • White Papers
      • COATLE Word Game
    • EVENTS
      • Coatings Trends & Technologies Summit
      • Paint and Coatings Academy
      • Webinars
      • Calendar of Events
      • Lifetime Achievement Award
    • DIRECTORIES
      • Buyer's Guide
      • Equipment Directory
      • Materials Directory
    • EMAGAZINE
      • Current Issue
      • eMagazine Archive
      • China Issue Archive
      • Editorial Advisory Board
    • CONTACT
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise
      • Subscribe to eMagazine
      • Subscribe to eNewsletters
    Moody’s Coating Conundrums

    Saul's Gloss Loss Solution

    By Keith M. Moody
    Moody Problem Article Image.jpg
    February 10, 2023

    In Saul’s Gloss Loss Problem, Saul Vance had changed the coupling solvent in the water-reducible alkyd formulation from ethylene glycol butyl ether (EB) to ethylene glycol propyl ether (EP) when he discovered the EB solvent came out of aqueous solution at the elevated cure temperature. Lindsay Doyle explained that EB solvent exhibited a Lower Critical Solution Temperature (LCST) that caused the coating to lose gloss upon cure. Now the EP solvent was demonstrating the same problem. Even though EP solvent didn’t have a LCST, what was the other critical property that caused the loss of gloss?

    Saul Vance knew that when applying waterborne coatings, like his water-reducible alkyd, controlling the humidity of the air is critical. The evaporation of water is directly related to the relative humidity of the air. Unlike the evaporation rate of most solvents, which is not affected by the relative humidity, the relative evaporation rate (RER) of water decreases linearly at 25º C from 0.31 RER at 0 relative humidity to 0 RER at 100% relative humidity. The higher the moisture in the air above the wet applied coating, the slower the water comes out of the coating film.

    Saul Vance also knew that the way air moisture is measured is by relative humidity. The relative humidity of the air is a measure of how much water vapor is in the air at a particular temperature compared with how much water vapor would be in the air at saturation. It is expressed as a ratio of the amount of water in a given amount of air divided by the maximum amount of water the air can hold at that temperature. The ratio is multiplied by 100 and expressed as a percentage.

    Al Kidd had visited the paint plant applying the coating. He knew that the owners had installed a state-of-the-art air handling system that controlled the humidity in the coating operation. He had also talked to the plant engineer and learned that the owners had not upgraded the plant insulation during the installation of the air handling equipment. The plant engineer reported that the outside temperature disrupted the temperature during coating, especially during the summer heat and winter cold.   The engineer said the expensive air handling units did keep the vapor content in the plant air constant. 


    Saul's Gloss Loss Solution

    Your browser does not support the audio element.

    For access to more podcast episodes, click here.


    Al told Saul that besides some glycol ethers having a Critical Lower Solution Temperature (LCST), many glycol ethers, like EB and EP, have relative evaporation rates between the extremes of the evaporation rate of water when varying the RH from 0 to 100%. EB has a relative evaporation rate of 0.08 while EP is more than twice as fast in evaporating with a relative evaporation rate of 0.2. Both have an RER less than the fastest RER for water at 0.31. For a blend of 15% EB and 85% water typical of the water-reducible alkyd during the flash-off phase, the relative humidity when the water and EB come off at the same speed, referred to as the Critical Relative Humidity (CRH), is approximately 82 %. When the relative humidity is lower than 82%, water comes off faster than EB and the coating becomes enriched in EB solvent. This solvent enriching is most often preferred to allow the coating to stay soluble and the pigments to stay dispersed during the drying process.

    The plant engineer had reported to Saul that the outside temperature had decreased dramatically for several nights before the gloss loss occurred. Al knew that the cold nights would decrease the temperature in the plant. Saul had assumed incorrectly that the relative humidity goes down with temperature since air doesn’t hold as much water at low temperatures. Al knew that since relative humidity is a ratio percentage, this temperature decrease has an inverse effect on relative humidity in the plant. The cooler temperature causes the relative humidity to increase. Cool air can’t hold as much water vapor (moisture) as warm air. Since relative humidity is a measure of the percentage saturation of the air, colder air doesn't require as much moisture to become saturated as warmer air. Since the amount of moisture in the plant air didn’t change and the absolute humidity is the same, the plant air will have a higher relative humidity when the air is cooler.

    When Saul changed the solvent from EB to EP, the blend of 15% EP and 85% water has identical relative evaporation rates when the relative humidity is 55%.  Now the Critical Relative Humidity for the EP and water is much lower and very close to the plant operating relative humidity of 50%. As long as the plant RH was less than the CRH of the glycol/ water blend, the formulation performed well and exhibited high gloss. As with the aqueous EB solvent earlier, when the relative humidity in the plant was below 55%, the water evaporated faster than the EP tail solvent, and the EP enriched the coating during the flash-off.

    The unseasonably cool nights caused the temperature to drop in the plant and the relative humidity increased to above 55%. Now, with the RH of the plant above the CRH of the EP/water blend, the water comes off slower than the EP solvent, and the coating is depleted of the EP coupling solvent.

    Al recognized how the cooler nights caused the shift in the evaporation rate of the EP and the water. Now the EP is too fast compared with the water. Because there is no coupling solvent left in the alkyd to act as a tail solvent and to help dissolve the resin, the resin precipitates out of solution, and the pigment agglomerates before the film is formed. This results in a coating with low gloss.

    Another way to ensure that the relative humidity is not a cause of coating film problems is to vary the air speed above the coating during the flash-off. The relative evaporation rate of water as well as the relative rate of evaporation of blends of water and glycol ethers depends on the air speed. Critical Relative Humidity is dependent on the air speed. Often with aqueous glycol ether blends, increasing the air speed during flash-off will decrease the Critical Relative Humidity of the blend. For example, a 15% EB/85% water blend has a CRH of 82% without any air movement above the film, but the CRH drops to 62% when the air speed is 2 miles per hour. Then when the air speed increased from 2 mph to 6 mph, the CRH drops to 48%. A change in air speed or a change in relative humidity may be used to get the same effect. Coating problems like sagging can often be minimized by balancing the coating conditions, like air speed and temperature, against relative humidity. 

    The way most formulators ensure that humidity doesn’t cause a problem is to use glycol ethers that are slower than EP and have a larger Critical Relative Humidity with water. These solvents almost always enrich in solvent and deplete in water during the flash-off and rarely cause loss of gloss. If Saul had left EB solvent in the aqueous blend, this blend would have had a CRH of about 85%, well above even the resulting CRH after the cool nights. Because the RH would have been less than 85%, the EB would still be slower than the water. This solvent enriching effect on the coating would have kept the gloss high even with the colder temperature. But the EB was changed because it demonstrated the Lower Critical Solution Temperature at the elevated temperature in the bake.

    In this example, Saul needed to be aware of two critical concepts, Lower Critical Solution Temperature, and Critical Relative Humidity. Both of these concepts are critical for all waterborne coating formulators to recognize and know how to control during the different stages of drying: application, flash-off, and baking. 

    For further information see: Dillon, Paul; “Application of Critical Relative Humidity, an Evaporation Analog of Azeotropy, to the Drying of Water-Borne Coatings”, Journal of Coatings Technology, Vol. 49, No. 634, November 1977.

    KEYWORDS: formulating tips Solvents

    Share This Story

    Looking for a reprint of this article?
    From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

    By Keith M. Moody, Training and Consulting, Johnson City, TN

    Recommended Content

    JOIN TODAY
    to unlock your recommendations.

    Already have an account? Sign In

    • PCI-0724-Global10-Feature-1440.png

      2024 Global Top 10: Top Paint and Coatings Companies

      Who ranks on top? PCI’s annual ranking of the top 10...
      Global Top 10 and PCI 25
      By: Courtney Bassett
    • PCI-0724-PCI25-Feature-1440.png

      2024 PCI 25: Top Paint and Coatings Companies

      PCI's annual ranking of the top 25 North American paint...
      Global Top 10 and PCI 25
      By: Courtney Bassett
    • pci1022-Kinaltek-Lead-1170.jpg

      A Novel Pigment Production Technology

      Following an extensive R&D program that demonstrated...
      Paint and Coating Pigments
      By: Jawad Haidar and Nitin Soni
    You must login or register in order to post a comment.

    Report Abusive Comment

    Subscribe For Free!
    • eMagazine
    • eNewsletter
    • Online Registration
    • Subscription Customer Service

    More Videos

    Sponsored Content

    Sponsored Content is a special paid section where industry companies provide high quality, objective, non-commercial content around topics of interest to the PCI audience. All Sponsored Content is supplied by the advertising company and any opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily reflect the views of PCI or its parent company, BNP Media. Interested in participating in our Sponsored Content section? Contact your local rep!

    close
    • paint sprayer in a workshop
      Sponsored byallnex

      Enabling Performance and Compliance: allnex Introduces a New Line of VOC Exempt Solvent-Borne Resins

    • various shades of orange pigments and colorants
      Sponsored byVibrantz Technologies

      Solid Colorant Technology Paves the Way for a Sustainable, High-Performance Future in Coatings

    Popular Stories

    Names-467607423.jpg

    Two PPG Scientists Earn Rare Honor

    Nippon news.jpg

    Biocide-Free Coating Passes Marine Life Safety Test

    Names (male), personnel announcements (1).jpg

    Beverage Industry Exec to Help Steer Sherwin-Williams



    PCI Buyers Guide

    Submit a Request for Proposal (RFP) to suppliers of your choice with details on what you need with a click of a button

    Start your RFP

    Browse our Buyers Guide for manufacturers and distributors of all types of coatings products and much more!

    Find Suppliers

    Events

    January 1, 2030

    Webinar Sponsorship Information

    For webinar sponsorship information, visit www.bnpevents.com/webinars or email webinars@bnpmedia.com.

    View All Submit An Event

    Poll

    Longest-running laboratory experiment

    What is the longest-running laboratory experiment?
    View Results Poll Archive

    Products

    Automotive Paints and Coatings, 2nd Edition

    Automotive Paints and Coatings, 2nd Edition

    Now in its second edition and still the only book of its kind, this is an authoritative treatment of all stages of the coating process.

    See More Products
    pci  webinar april 2025

    PCI CASE EBOOK

    Related Articles

    • moodys coating conundrums

      The Solution to Saul’s Double Rub Debacle

      See More
    • moodys

      Moody's Coatings Conundrums: Saul’s Un-Sellable Formulation

      See More
    • Moody's coating conundrums

      Moody's Coatings Conundrums: Answer to Saul’s Un-Sellable Formulation

      See More

    Related Products

    See More Products
    • pce feb 2020

      PCI February 2020 Issue

    • Part two: Advanced Powder Coatings Formulation (Zoom course 10/23/25)

    • biopolymer.jpg

      Biopolymer-Based Films and Coatings Trends and Challenges

    See More Products
    ×

    Keep the info flowing with our eNewsletters!

    Get the latest industry updates tailored your way.

    JOIN TODAY!
    • RESOURCES
      • Advertise
      • Contact Us
      • Directories
      • Store
      • Want More
    • SIGN UP TODAY
      • Create Account
      • eMagazine
      • eNewsletters
      • Customer Service
      • Manage Preferences
    • SERVICES
      • Marketing Services
      • Reprints
      • Market Research
      • List Rental
      • Survey & Sample
    • STAY CONNECTED
      • LinkedIn
      • Facebook
      • Youtube
      • X (Twitter)
    • PRIVACY
      • PRIVACY POLICY
      • TERMS & CONDITIONS
      • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
      • PRIVACY REQUEST
      • ACCESSIBILITY

    Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

    Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing